November 18, 2026
Markets allocate capital, but society grants legitimacy. Participation and sensible regulation need to arrive before the bulldozers, not after.
‘Big Tech was a danger to Democracy’
At the recent Mumbai Literature Festival, I was part of the Big Debate, arguing that ‘Big Tech was a danger to Democracy’. I spoke for the motion, making the case that a few corporations had accumulated an alarming amount of technological, economic and informational power. We lost. Our opponents argued that we were underestimating democracy, which has survived emperors, ideologies and all manner of powerful men, and was quite capable of surviving Silicon Valley too. I was disappointed, naturally, but also secretly glad they won. The recent American midterm results have vindicated that judgement and made me happier.
On 3 November, Americans delivered a blue wave, handing Democrats control of both houses of Congress. Two days later, Wall Street had its own verdict: roughly $2.5 trillion vanished from Nasdaq valuations in a day as AI stocks tumbled. Americans had voted on Donald Trump, the economy and a host of other concerns. But had they also cast a vote on AI? I suspect not: Democrats are hardly Luddites, and beating China in the AI race is one of the few ambitions that still attracts support across America’s political divide. The objection is less to artificial intelligence than to the extraordinary power of the people who own it. Who decides how AI develops? Who enjoys its riches? Who picks up the bill? These are questions confined to technology conferences; now they have arrived at the ballot box.
The Cloud Has Acquired an Address
And their unlikely poster child is the data centre. For years AI lived somewhere mysterious called ‘the cloud’, which sounded reassuringly weightless. Now the cloud has acquired an address, a vast electricity connection and a considerable thirst for water. Data centres have become the physical symbol of the AI boom, and for communities confronting higher power bills or pressure on local resources, an unwelcome neighbour. Opposition to their proliferation surfaced in election campaigns and local ballot measures. It is difficult to tell voters that the future is glorious when the present comes with a bigger electricity bill, environmental degradation, and a sinking water table.
This does not mean America will stop building data centres. There is too much money, national ambition and strategic necessity involved, and the Trump White House is hardly about to tamp down its bulldozing intention. Democratic control of Congress will bring more hearings, scrutiny and proposed safeguards, though presidential vetoes may limit what becomes law. But, importantly, the way data centres are built may change. Local people will want a say in what happens to their land, water and electricity, and a fair share of the benefits. A permit from the authorities may no longer suffice; companies will need permission of a less formal but more durable kind, from the communities around them.
Society Grants Legitimacy
That brings us to a principle capitalism sometimes forgets: markets allocate capital, but society grants legitimacy. Corporations do not float above the societies that provide their workers, customers, infrastructure and resources. Their licence to operate is ultimately social. Yet the AI race sometimes seemed to make the public look like an inconvenient competitor for scarce inputs. Sam Altman recently suggested that computer memory sitting largely unused in people’s PCs might be better deployed in cloud data centres. Reportedly, Jeff Bezos grumbled about humans consuming too much water! While the Bezos story was debunked, it still revealed a stark question: who is AI and its data centre for, and who gets to decide?
Giving millions of people access to AI is one kind of democratisation, but giving them a meaningful say in how AI’s power is exercised is quite another. The models, chips, cloud platforms and capital remain concentrated with a small club. The political response may therefore be aimed less at slowing down technology and AI, and more at checking the billionaires who control its infrastructure. The financial markets offer a second irony. Investors have spent months asking the hyperscalers whether their enormous AI spending will ever earn equally enormous returns. Now political resistance might do what anxious analysts could not, and slow the spending spree. That could improve cash flows and make existing data-centre capacity more valuable. It helps explain why some established tech giants initially rallied even while infrastructure stocks fell. Of course, slow the build-out too much and future growth suffers. But the assumption that every brake on AI investment is bad for Big Tech deserves a second look. It is the invention of brakes that made automobiles drive faster.
Before the Bulldozers, Not After
India has reasons to watch both the markets and the neighbourhood protests. Foreign investors have been drawn towards the American AI trade, while India has offered relatively few listed companies with comparable exposure. If some of that enthusiasm cools, Indian equities could attract renewed attention, although foreign flows depend on much more than AI alone. And as American projects face delays or higher costs, India could compete for some infrastructure investment, provided our electricity, connectivity and policy conditions are right.
The larger lesson, however, is not about attracting dollars. India too is racing to build data centres and sovereign computing capacity. We should not mistake an investment announcement for a social contract. If we disregard communities, water, land and the environment in our eagerness to build, we may discover the same resistance, only later and at greater cost. Participation and sensible regulation need to arrive before the bulldozers, not after. Which returns me to that Mumbai debate. I still believe concentrated technological power can threaten democracy. But my opponents were right to remind me that democracy has hidden reserves of strength. Silicon and capital may power the AI revolution, but they do not grant it an unlimited licence. For that, even the world’s richest companies must eventually turn to the people.
January 17, 2025
January 03, 2025
December 20, 2024
December 06, 2024
November 22, 2024
November 08, 2024
October 24, 2024
October 11, 2024
August 16, 2024
August 02, 2024